Posted by Stefan Hunter on Apr 01, 2025
How to Fix a Mattress That’s Too Hard | DOWNLITE Bedding
Waking up with aches and pains? Are you struggling to fall asleep because your mattress feels more like a wooden board than a cozy bed? You’re not alone. A mattress that’s too firm can wreak havoc on your comfort, alignment, and sleep quality. Fortunately, you don’t have to replace your bed to soften things. In this guide, we’ll explore why mattresses can feel too hard—and how you can fix it with one easy upgrade: a thick mattress pad.
Why Is My Mattress So Hard?
There are several reasons your mattress may feel too firm, even if it’s new:
1. New Mattress Break-In Period
Many mattresses need a break-in period, especially those with high-density foam or innerspring construction. That brand-new firmness might soften after 30–60 days but can feel stiff.
2. Sleeping Position Mismatch
Side sleepers, in particular, need more cushioning to relieve pressure on shoulders and hips. A mattress that feels fine for a back sleeper might feel rock-hard to someone who sleeps on their side.
3. Too-Firm Mattress Type
Mattresses labeled “firm” or “extra-firm” may provide support, but without enough plushness, they can compress joints and restrict circulation.
4. Temperature Sensitivity
Some foam mattresses become firmer in cooler rooms and may take longer to conform to your body.
Whatever the cause, one thing is clear: if your mattress is too hard, you’re likely not sleeping your best.
The Best Solution: Add a Thick Mattress Pad
Before buying a whole new mattress—or even a plush mattress topper like a feather bed—try a more straightforward, more manageable fix: a thick, high-loft mattress pad. At DOWNLITE, we specialize in mattress pads that transform overly firm beds into cozy, sleep-friendly havens without sacrificing support.
Why Choose a Thick Mattress Pad?
- Instant Softness: Our plush mattress pads add an extra layer of comfort between you and your mattress, helping to ease pressure on hips, shoulders, and knees.
- Easy to Wash: Unlike featherbeds or fiber beds that require dry cleaning or spot care, our mattress pads are machine washable and dryer-safe in large-size home machines. Alternatively, you could wash them through a dry cleaner (make sure to launder and NOT dry clean).
- Secure Fit: Many of our pads feature stretch skirt designs that stay in place without bunching or shifting. Our mattress pad skirts stretch and fit up to 18 inches in height!
- USA Assembled Quality: We’re proud to assemble many of our pads in the USA using premium materials and craftsmanship.
- Affordable Alternative: At a fraction of the cost of a new mattress or even a luxury topper, our pads are a budget-friendly way to make your bed feel brand new.
What to Look for in a Mattress Pad for Firm Beds
A mattress pad is great to consider if you’re trying to soften a hard bed. Here are the features that matter most:
✔️ High Loft Fill
Look for mattress pads labeled "extra plush" or "thick." Fill materials like down alternative polyester clusters offer softness while still being easy to care for.
✔️ Box Quilting
This keeps the fill evenly distributed, so you won’t get lumpy spots or thin areas over time.
✔️ Deep Pocket Design
Ensure the pad fits snugly over your mattress, especially if you have a pillow-top or taller mattress.
✔️ Breathable Materials
Cotton-blend shells and breathable fills help prevent overheating—a common issue with some thick toppers. We also love materials like TENCEL or bamboo.
A Note on Feather beds and Fiber beds
At DOWNLITE, we also offer luxurious feather beds and fiber beds for those who want a traditional hotel-like experience. While they provide deep cushioning, they require more maintenance: feather beds need fluffing and occasional dry cleaning, and fiber beds aren’t always machine washable due to their structure. That’s why we usually recommend starting with a thick mattress pad—it’s easier to care for, more durable, and just as effective for most sleepers.
BONUS: Combine a Pad with a Plush Pillow for Total Comfort
Softening your mattress is only part of the equation. If your head and neck aren’t supported properly, you could still wake up with stiffness. Consider pairing your mattress pad with one of our:
- Soft pillows for stomach sleepers
- Adjustable 3-in-1 pillows for side and back sleepers
- Down or down alternative fill options for comfort and support
Together, a plush mattress pad and the right pillow can create a luxurious sleep experience without the cost of a whole new bed.
Shop DOWNLITE Mattress Pads That Soften Hard Beds
Whether you’re looking to rescue a too-firm guest bed or finally soften your mattress, DOWNLITE’s selection of thick, USA-assembled mattress pads is a smart place to start. Popular options include:
Explore our entire collection to find the perfect fit for your bed size and comfort preferences.
Final Thoughts
You don’t have to suffer through sleepless nights on a rock-hard mattress. With the right thick mattress pad from DOWNLITE, you can add comfort and softness where you need it—quickly, affordably, and without hassle.
Ready to fix your too-hard bed?
Shop our bestselling mattress pads and enjoy a better night's sleep tonight.